Fixed Rate or Variable Rate: Which Type of Mortgage Is Right for You?

The honest trade-offs between fixed and variable rate mortgages, what each costs in 2026, and the question that decides the answer.

The thing that surprises most first-time borrowers about the fixed-versus-variable question is how lopsided the answer has been for the past decade. Around 90% of UK mortgages taken out in the last few years have been on fixed rates. There is a reason for that, and it is not just preference. Variable products have been priced poorly relative to fixes for most of that period, and the certainty fixed rates offer is, for most people, worth the small premium. But variable is not pointless. There are situations it suits. Here is the honest version.

How a fixed rate actually works

A fix locks your interest rate for an agreed period, usually 2, 3, 5, or occasionally 10 years. Your monthly payment does not move during that period, regardless of what the Bank of England does with the base rate. That is the whole point. As of spring 2026, 5-year fixes are sitting somewhere around 4.2% to 4.6% for residential borrowers with a 25% deposit, and 2-year fixes tend to come in slightly higher because the lender is taking less rate risk. Worth knowing that the fix length affects pricing in unintuitive ways, not always linearly.

When the fix ends, you revert to the lender’s Standard Variable Rate. The SVR is almost always uncompetitive (it is what the lender charges when you stop paying attention), and the gap between SVR and a fresh fix can easily be 2 or 3 percentage points. That is why we tell clients to start the remortgage conversation 6 months before their fix ends. Not 6 weeks. Six months.

How variable rate products actually work

There are two main variable products people compare against fixes. A tracker follows the Bank of England base rate plus a fixed margin. So a tracker at ‘base + 0.79%’ moves with the BoE rate, up or down. A discounted variable is set at a discount to the lender’s SVR for an introductory period, after which it floats up. In practice, trackers are the more transparent of the two, because the SVR can be moved by the lender independently of the BoE.

Variable rates are usually cheaper than fixes when interest rates are expected to fall, and more expensive when rates are expected to rise. Lenders price these products based on what their treasury teams think is coming. Sometimes the market is right, sometimes it is wrong. Worth knowing that some trackers come without early repayment charges, which makes them genuinely useful if you might pay the mortgage off early or sell the property.

The actual question to ask yourself

It is not ‘which one is cheaper’. The honest answer is that both have been cheaper at different points in the cycle, and predicting interest rates over the next 5 years is something even the BoE struggles with. The actual question is: how much would a £200 jump in your monthly payment hurt? If the answer is ‘a lot, that would tip me over’, a fix is the right answer almost regardless of price, because you are buying certainty. If the answer is ‘I have plenty of buffer and I would rather not pay the certainty premium’, variable can make sense.

Most clients pick fixed because most household budgets are sensitive to a £200 monthly swing. Particularly true for first-time buyers who have stretched on the deposit and are not sitting on a thick layer of savings. Some clients (often professionals with high disposable income, or people approaching the end of their mortgage with low balances) genuinely sit better on a tracker. Both decisions are reasonable. The wrong one is picking blind without running the figures.

Conclusion

We compare both routes for every client and put the actual numbers next to each other before recommending one.

Risk warning: We offer an unrestricted range of first charge mortgages, but do not offer second charge lending or bridging finance. We also do not offer mortgage deals which are only available direct from the lender.

Not Sure Which Mortgage Option is Right for You?

That is exactly what we are here for. Get in touch for a free chat and we will quickly help you work out which type of mortgage fits your situation best.