Income Protection Insurance: The Policy Most People Do Not Have But Should

Income protection is the most under-bought protection product in the UK. The honest case for it: what it covers, what it costs, and why it should usually come before life insurance.

Of the three main mortgage-protection products (life insurance, critical illness cover, income protection), income protection is the one that statistically should claim most often during a working life and the one that fewest people actually own. ABI figures consistently show income protection penetration in the UK below 10%, against life insurance penetration above 30%. This is upside-down relative to the actual probability of needing each product. Worth thinking about why.

What it actually does

Income protection pays a regular monthly income if you cannot work due to illness or injury. The benefit starts after a chosen ‘deferred period’ (commonly 4, 8, 13, 26, or 52 weeks, picked to match when employer sick pay ends), and continues until you return to work, the policy ends, or you reach the maximum benefit period (usually until age 65 or 70). The monthly benefit is typically 50% to 65% of your gross earnings, capped to ensure incentive to return to work.

Critically, income protection covers any illness or injury preventing you from working, not just specific listed conditions. So musculoskeletal injuries (back pain, joint problems, RSI), mental health (depression, anxiety, breakdown), chronic conditions without specific severe diagnoses, and the long-tail recoveries from accidents and surgeries are all covered. Critical illness, by contrast, only pays for specific listed conditions meeting strict definitions. The difference between the two products in real claim experience is substantial.

Why it is so under-bought

Three reasons, in my experience. First, life insurance is the most heavily marketed of the three, partly because mortgage lenders bundle it with mortgage applications. Income protection is rarely flagged at the same point. Second, the perceived cost is higher than people expect (income protection genuinely is more expensive than life insurance for the same person), and the complexity of choosing deferred periods and benefit terms puts buyers off. Third, employed people often assume their employer’s sick pay will cover them, without checking the actual terms.

On the third point: most employer sick pay schemes pay full salary for a short period (often 4 to 12 weeks), then half salary for a similar period, then statutory sick pay only (£116.75 a week as of 2025/26, which does not cover most mortgages). The ‘I have sick pay through work’ view often turns out to mean ‘4 weeks of full pay then nothing useful’. By far the most common gap is between when employer sick pay drops and when the person actually returns to work, and that gap is what income protection fills.

The cost reality

Income protection is more expensive than equivalent life insurance, typically 2 to 4 times the cost. For a healthy 35-year-old non-smoker, an income protection policy covering £2,500 a month, with a 13-week deferred period, paying to age 65, might cost £25 to £50 a month. The same person’s £200,000 decreasing life cover might cost £15 a month. So the income protection costs more, and there is a real reason for that: claims frequency is genuinely higher.

The cost can be controlled by adjusting the deferred period (longer deferred period means cheaper premium), the benefit term (covering only 5 years rather than to age 65 is cheaper), and the benefit amount. Many clients take a longer deferred period (say 26 weeks rather than 4 weeks) because they have employer sick pay covering the early months, which can roughly halve the premium. Honestly, the tailoring is where the advice work happens, and the right structure for one client is the wrong structure for another. Worth doing properly.

Conclusion

Most clients are surprised at how much cover £30 a month actually buys.

Risk warning: We offer products from a carefully selected number of insurers to provide a fair analysis of the market for Income Protection, Critical Illness Insurance, and Life Assurance. For Accident, Sickness and Unemployment we offer cover provided by Allianz and MetLife.

Not Sure Which Insurance Product is Right for You?

That is exactly what we are here for. Get in touch for a free chat and we will quickly help you work out which type of insurance fits your situation best.