Life insurance is the protection product most people think of first, and it covers an important risk. The trouble is, the risk it covers (death during your working-age years) is significantly less likely than the risks it doesn’t (serious illness, extended periods off work, accidents that do not kill but seriously affect earning capacity). For households with mortgages and dependants, life insurance alone leaves the most likely scenarios unprotected. Worth thinking about which risks your protection actually addresses.
The probability picture
For a typical UK 35-year-old, the probability of dying before age 65 is in the region of 5% to 8%, depending on lifestyle factors. The probability of being diagnosed with cancer during their lifetime is around 50% (Cancer Research UK figures). The probability of being off work for a month or more due to illness or injury during a working life is around 25%, per ABI data. And the probability of having a serious health event (heart attack, stroke, cancer, major surgery) at some point during a working life is meaningful enough to plan for.
Life insurance covers the small probability event with a large impact (death). Critical illness and income protection cover the larger probability events with smaller individual impacts (serious illness, extended time off work). Both kinds of risk matter. A protection plan that only addresses the death risk is leaving the more probable risks uninsured, which is an unusual choice once stated plainly.
The cases I see most often
A few months back I had a client whose husband had been signed off work for 11 months with a serious back injury after a fall. He had life insurance, decreasing term, perfect policy for the mortgage if he died. He didn’t die. He was just unable to work. Statutory sick pay had run out months earlier. Their savings were gone. Their mortgage arrears were building. Life insurance was no help to them at all. Income protection would have been. The conversation about why he didn’t have it was uncomfortable.
Similar cases recur regularly: cancer diagnosed in a 41-year-old who is off treatment for 9 months, mental health crisis putting a parent off work for 14 months, severe RSI ending a manual worker’s career, sudden chronic illness with no specific severe diagnosis but ongoing inability to work. None of these are death claims. All of them are income disruption events that life insurance does not pay for. By far the most common protection failure I see is not ‘we did not have any cover’. It is ‘we had life insurance but the actual event was not death’.
What a fuller protection plan looks like
A more complete protection plan combines: life insurance to clear the mortgage and support dependants on death, critical illness cover to provide a lump sum on diagnosis of specified serious conditions (which can clear the mortgage and fund treatment costs), and income protection to replace a portion of income during extended periods off work for any reason. Each one addresses a different scenario, and the combination covers the bulk of the risk.
The cost of all three is typically lower than people expect. For a healthy 35-year-old non-smoker with a £200,000 mortgage, a 25-year combination of decreasing life cover, decreasing critical illness, and income protection might cost £45 to £80 a month total. More than life insurance alone, certainly. But considerably broader than life alone, and addressing the actual probability profile of what is likely to go wrong. For households with dependants and a mortgage, the combination is usually the right answer.
Conclusion
We are happy to tell you when you have enough already.
Risk warning: We offer products from a carefully selected number of insurers to provide a fair analysis of the market for Income Protection, Critical Illness Insurance, and Life Assurance. For Accident, Sickness and Unemployment we offer cover provided by Allianz and MetLife.