A client came in a few months back with roughly £22,000 across four credit cards, all at rates between 19% and 24%. Minimum payments were swallowing most of her disposable income, and she was one late payment away from a real credit problem. Her question was the one I get every other week: could she add the £22,000 to her mortgage and clear it all in one go? Yes, technically. Should she? That is the actual question, and the honest answer is: it depends, and not in the reassuring way people usually mean when they say that.
The maths that makes it look attractive
On paper, debt consolidation via remortgage is genuinely compelling. £22,000 of credit card debt at 21% APR costs roughly £385 a month in interest alone. Adding that same £22,000 to a mortgage at 5% adds roughly £128 a month over a 25-year term to the mortgage payment (capital and interest combined). The monthly cash flow relief is real, immediate, and can be the difference between managing and drowning. For a household that is one bad month away from missing a card payment, that relief matters.
The other maths that works: consolidation moves the debt off unsecured cards (where APRs can spike unexpectedly if you miss a payment) onto a fixed-rate mortgage where the rate is locked for the fix period. The certainty of the monthly figure has value beyond the headline saving. And for borrowers with adverse credit already registering against them, moving debt onto the mortgage can slow the credit file damage that further missed card payments would cause. So far, so reasonable. This is why the advert version of debt consolidation sells.
The maths that makes it dangerous
Here is what the £128 monthly figure hides. Over 25 years, that £22,000 consolidated at 5% mortgage rate costs roughly £38,500 total (capital plus interest). The credit card debt at 21%, if paid off aggressively over 3 to 5 years, would cost roughly £30,000 to £34,000 total. So the mortgage version, over its full term, costs more. It only looks cheaper monthly because the debt is stretched over a much longer period. Most people running the numbers do not see this because they only look at the monthly figure.
The bigger risk is behavioural. Consolidation clears the credit cards, which means the credit cards are then available again, with £22,000 of headroom. About one in four consolidation clients I see (not a hard number, this is my sense of the pattern) has racked up new card debt within 2 years of consolidating the old debt. Which means they are now paying off the consolidated debt on the mortgage AND fresh card debt at 21%. The consolidation did not solve the underlying problem, and now the debt is higher than it was before. This is the scenario that keeps me up at night, and it is why I push back on some consolidation requests that on paper look sensible.
When it genuinely helps
Debt consolidation is the right move when three things are true. First, the underlying spending has been fixed. Not ‘will be fixed after we consolidate’, not ‘we are working on it’, but genuinely fixed: budget in place, cards cut up (physically), a plan for the household finances that everyone in the household has agreed to. Second, the borrower has enough equity in the property to consolidate without pushing LTV too high (below 75% ideally, certainly below 85%). And third, the borrower’s income situation is stable enough that adding to the mortgage debt does not create fresh risk.
Where those three conditions apply, consolidation is genuinely valuable and I will help arrange it without hesitation. Specialist lenders (Pepper Money, Kensington, Vida) offer debt consolidation remortgages up to 85% LTV even with some historic adverse credit, at rates typically 1.5% to 2.5% above prime residential rates. Mainstream lenders (Halifax, Nationwide) will consider consolidation for clean credit files up to 75% LTV. The right lender depends on the specific situation, and this is exactly the kind of case where broker advice earns its keep, because getting the maths and the lender choice right genuinely changes the outcome.
If you are thinking about consolidating debt into your mortgage, phone 01604 552100 (Monday to Friday, 9am to 6pm) for a free first call. I will run the numbers honestly, including the numbers that make it look worse than the headline saving suggests. Sometimes we will conclude it is the right move. Sometimes we will conclude it is not, and I will send you away with a different plan. Better that than the alternative.
Remortgages: Signs It Is Time to Remortgage Remortgages: How to Remortgage to Release Equity Adverse Credit: How to Improve Your Credit Score
Risk warning: We offer an unrestricted range of first charge mortgages, but do not offer second charge lending or bridging finance. We also do not offer mortgage deals which are only available direct from the lender.